Guidance for assessing depression in the GP surgery and when to refer to specialist care

In this quarter’s GP newsletter blog, Sean Lonergan, Cognitive Behavioural Psychotherapist, Mood Disorders Service at St Patrick’s Mental Health Services (SPMHS) provides guidance on how best to understand the different ways depression can present and the best principles and practices that can guide treatment planning, including when to refer to specialist care.

As GPs, you often provide the first opportunity for patients to be diagnosed with depression. As GPs in Ireland you act as the primary, central point of access for mental health support, offering assessments, referrals and treatment plans for issues like anxiety and depression. GPs often provide the most enduring support for those living with depression.

Supporting patients with depression is aided through careful assessment, seeking collateral information, establishing and maintaining links with referral and support services and providing education and support to patients and their families.

What is depression?

What is depression?

Depression is more than normal sadness or stress response which affects mood, thinking, physical health and behaviour. The core symptoms of depression, according to the DSM‑5/ICD‑11, must include depressed mood OR loss of interest/pleasure plus three or four of the following:

  • Sleep disturbance
  • Appetite/weight change
  • Fatigue, low energy
  • Poor concentration
  • Feelings of guilt/worthlessness
  • Psychomotor change
  • Suicidal ideation.

Major depressive disorder requires symptoms to be persistent for more than two weeks with significant functional impairment. Symptoms cannot be caused by substances or better explained by another medical condition. Symptoms cause clinically significant distress or impairment in social, occupational, or other important areas of functioning.

Depression sub-types with specific presentations

Depression sub-types with specific presentations

  • Major depressive disorder
  • Persistent depressive disorder / dysthymia
  • Recurrent depression
  • Perinatal / postnatal depression
  • Depression with psychotic features
  • Bipolar depression → important to avoid misdiagnosis.

Approaching conversations about depression and low mood with patients

Approaching conversations about depression and low mood with patients

When trying to identify and diagnose depression in a busy GP clinic it can help to slow down, or in the first 60 seconds, to try to observe and notice your patient’s presentation without assumption. It may be helpful to ask explicitly about low mood without judgement; to reassure about time if patients fear “burdening” their GP; to respond with compassion and validation to aid rapport and trust- building. Patient-centred communication is fostered by creating a safe disclosure environment through warmth, patience and empathy, signalling safety early; patients decide within seconds that they feel safe to disclose emotional distress.

It is important to ask about suicide risk directly and take immediate action if high-risk of harm is identified, with an urgent referral/emergency department referral and safety planning. Patients rarely offer this information voluntarily and helpful questions that you can ask may include over the past two weeks have you experienced:

  • Thoughts of being better off dead?
  • Thoughts of harming themselves?
  • Any plan or preparation?
  • What has stopped you from acting on these thoughts/plans to end your life?

When assessing functional impact, which is an important severity marker of depression, it can help to ask about work performance, absenteeism, social withdrawal and quality of relationships and self-care.

Challenges to diagnosing depression

Challenges to diagnosing depression

There can be challenges to accurately diagnosis depression as two‑thirds of patients may present to GPs with physical symptoms only such as fatigue, sleep problems, headaches or chronic pain and gastrointestinal symptoms. If you suspect your patient may be depressed the two PHQ2 questions outlined in the table below can help explore this. Ask your patient – “over the past two weeks, how often have you been bothered by any of the following problems: feeling down, depressed or hopeless; and little interest or pleasure in doing things.

Patient Health Questionnaire

Patient Health Questionnaire

Bipolar disorder and psychosis symptoms

Bipolar disorder and psychosis symptoms

If depression symptoms are identified, it is important to assess if your patient has experienced hypomania or mania symptoms in the past and/or psychosis symptoms.

Ante and postnatal depression

Ante and postnatal depression

The World Health Organisation (WHO) describe a high prevalence of antenatal and postnatal depression of between 10% and 13% (Mental Health, Brain Health and Substance Use). This makes early diagnosis and treatment a high priority for the wellbeing of the mother, child and family unit. Specific sensitively asked questions can include:

  • If the patient is having any difficulties caring for herself or the baby
  • If the patient experiences any intrusive thoughts about harming herself or the baby.

These questions can help identify if depression may be present. If ante/postnatal depression is diagnosed, consider psychotherapy first and if prescribing medication, sertraline if preferred.

Depression in older adults

Depression in older adults

Older adults often present with more somatic symptoms, sleep disturbances and anxiety symptoms. Some 60-70% of people with dementia experience symptoms of depression and/or anxiety, therefore considering assessment of cognitive impairment versus depression using the Mini-Mental State Examination (MMSE) may be indicated.

Depression, insomnia and sleep disorders

Depression, insomnia and sleep disorders

Sleep and depression have a strong bidirectional relationship. Insomnia doubles the risk of developing depression (Baglioni et al., 2011). Treating sleep disorders improves mood, functioning and relapse prevention.

Common sleep disorders to rule out include insomnia disorder, sleep apnoea, parasomnias and hypersomnia. If a specific sleep disorder is indicated, specialist referral pathways in Ireland include:

When to refer patients presenting with depression to specialist services

When to refer patients presenting with depression to specialist services

Follow the National Institute of clinical excellence (NICE) guidelines:

  • Step 1: Assessment, referral, psychoeducation, monitoring and support.
  • Step 2: Low-intensity therapy for mild depression.
  • Step 3: Anti-depressants + high-intensity therapy for moderate to severe depression.
  • Step 4: Specialist care for complex, high-risk, psychotic or treatment-resistant depression.

Referral options include:

  • GP → Community mental health team
  • GP → Primary care psychology (where available)
  • GP → Counselling in primary care
  • GP → Specialist perinatal mental health services
  • GP → Private psychology/CBT therapists

Urgent versus routine referrals to specialist mental health services

Urgent versus routine referrals to specialist mental health services

GPs can make an urgent referral if there is:

  • High suicide risk
  • Psychotic symptoms
  • Severe functional decline
  • Severe agitation or mania
  • Pregnancy/postnatal depression with moderate to severe symptoms.

GPs can make a routine referral if there is:

  • Treatment-resistant depression
  • Diagnostic uncertainty
  • Comorbid substance misuse.

If you identify treatment-resistant depression, which you might suspect when there has been no response after two adequate trials of anti-depressants, it may be helpful to consider:

  • Reassessing the diagnosis (bipolar disorder? substance use?)
  • Assess what the therapeutic optimal dose for your patient is
  • Switch/augment anti-depressant
  • Add psychotherapy
  • Referral to specialist mental health services.

Day programmes and cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT)

Day programmes and cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT)

St Patrick’s Mental Health Services provides a Depression Recovery Programme and Bipolar Recovery programme, as well as a range of other day programmes GPs can refer directly to. Learn more here.

CBT can be accessed via St Patrick’s Mental Health Services. Complete a referral form and send to referrals@stpatricks.ie (Dean Clinic outpatient: Four to six weeks to review for suitability).

There are also HSE/community mental health team CBT provisions dependent on the county. CIPC/NCS for mild–moderate presentations. More information here.

The following websites list private accredited therapists:

In summary

In summary

Depression is common and often presents somatically.

Making your consultation approach compassionate, open and sensitive to the needs of patients presenting with depression can help aid diagnosis and effective intervention.

The PHQ‑2/PHQ‑9 are practical tools for aiding diagnosis and monitoring. It is important to match the treatment step to severity and treatment response; it is often helpful to combine medications and therapy for best outcomes.

Always assess suicide risk directly and be familiar with local and national referral options. Early intervention improves outcomes and reduces suicide risk.

Recommended treatments for mild depression include:

Recommended treatments for moderate depression include:

  • Prescribe SSRI as first-line antidepressant (ADT)
  • CBT / Interpersonal psychotherapy (IPT) / Behavioural activation (BA) referral
  • Lifestyle interventions continue
  • Review in two to three weeks
  • Use PHQ‑9 to track improvement.

Recommended treatments for severe depression include:

  • SSRI or SNRI
  • Consider combination with therapy
  • Safety planning
  • Regular monitoring
  • Assess for bipolar symptoms.